Owning Pink Bloggers

Don’t let the same things slide every day. Find balance to find joy.

Blowing the Whistle on Life Coaches

Melanie Bates's picture

 

These days everywhere I look I see the term “Coach." There are Life Coaches, Wellness Coaches, Health Coaches, Spiritual Coaches…  you name it and I’ll bet my scrawny ass there’s a Coach for it.

To be very frank this hasn’t sat very well with me since the term first began being bandied about. The word “Coach” brought up repressed memories of a potato sack relay in 4th grade where I placed 5th and an image of Beulah Balbricker of “Porky’s” fame. I was 12 when I watched Porky’s for the first time and Beulah formed a scarier figure in my psyche than Jason Myers and Freddie Kreuger combined. Not only would Beulah yank on my proverbial dong, she would delight in my pain. 

My Life Coaches

My first Coach was my step-father. Every day when he got home from work he would change into his gray, shiny gym shorts and white sneakers, grab the basketball, and inform me we were going to "practice." I hated it. I would sit cuddled on the couch with my nose pressed into a Nancy Drew mystery and instantly my soul would fill with dread. Then I would whine, “I don’t want to play basketball.” There was no arguing with my step-dad. Ever. Off we would go to the middle school basketball courts and he would spend two or more hours drilling me on my faults. “Follow through.” “You’re horrible.” “You need to practice, tomorrow it will be three hours.” I don’t recall ever having won a “game” with my step-dad.

While I don’t remember the name of my second coach, I do remember the shrillness of her whistle as I tried to pull myself up the gym rope to reach the far off red flag on the ceiling. My little hands would burn and my inner thighs would chafe and I’d look down at all of my classmates staring at me, my Coach blowing her whistle and yelling, “CLIMB… Don’t look down. CLIMB.” I realize now it was fear of the laughter of my peers that got me to the ceiling, not any particularly pressing desire of my own to get there.

My last coach memory was my high school gym teacher who happened to head up the track team. At the beginning of the year Coach Sess would run timed drills in 60-meter sprints and I ran so fast that she asked me to be on her coveted team. I was thrilled, perplexed, and honored and joined track for two weeks until the “head pack of boys” in our high school started making fun of how I ran. It didn’t seem to matter that I was lightning fast, it did matter, however, that apparently I looked like a fool doing so. 

As I sit here pondering my “Coaches” thus far in life, and as I rifle through my blue, red, and green ribbons and 1st place certificates, I realize that while I was good at sports as a kid, I didn’t feel joy in them. I ran, dribbled, hurdled, and passed the baton throughout school in fear, in trying to belong, and in thinking that just one victory might secure my stepfather’s love.

Whistle Blowing

Well, HELLO… no wonder I have issues with the term “Coach.” Ding, ding, ding, what have we got for her Johnny? I decided that I needed to put some salve on my mental rope burns and call my new friend Fred Krazeise who just happens to be a Wellness Coach.  

I asked Fred about the philosophy behind his coaching and how he would describe it. Fred told me that he believes that everyone is a creative, capable, and complete being and his job is to help folks to see that. In other words, one of his “duties” is to help his clients see themselves the way the rest of the world sees them; as whole, perfect beings. He also gave me some points on how to look for a coach and some of the most common thinking errors:

  • Shop around & ask the hard questions. Be a smart consumer. Try a Coach “on” to see if they fit with you. You need to feel comfortable with your Coach and you need to be able to build a relationship with said Coach.
  • The good Coaches have training and tools at their disposal. They are empathetic, caring, and have skill sets to guide their clients toward their goals. Coaches don’t “prescribe.”
  • The goals of a good Coach are to help their client fly on their own wings (not to keep blowing whistles until the end of time). Reputable Coaches want to see you succeed and not need their services until you’re both gray and rocking on a front porch of their practice in fifty years.
  • Coaches are not therapists. Your past may indeed come up but the important focus is placed on making changes in your life from today onward. 
  • Most folks have trouble receiving. Particularly women. Hiring a coach feels indulgent, like getting a massage when you’re saving up to pay your gas bill. People think that coaching is for the rich, the famous; like Botox - something you might like the idea of but would never fork out the dough for. And, to be frank, women in general are usually pretty tied up taking care of everyone else but themselves. 

I ended the conversation with Fred asking, “So… would you say a Coach is really like having a best friend?” According to him it is, to a certain extent, but often your best friends don’t have the skill sets to guide you, nor are they able to give you the tough love, or set you fully free to fly. A Coach doesn’t just listen; a Coach guides. A Coach pulls that salve out of their tool box for your own mental rope burns but they let you put it on yourself. You decide if you climb to the top of the rope and reach the flag and, more importantly, you set your intentions as to why you’re climbing in the first place.

Wowza. Sign me up -- but for love, not whistles, for achievement, not rope burns!

Ironically enough, or not (as I believe), Lissa is starting a Coaching Practice. I read her testimonial from Patricia, "Lissa shoots an arrow of love and acceptance through your heart, and that commands change. When I’m tired and don’t think I have the energy to change, she brilliantly points out the next step. When I’m resistant to change, she fearlessly points me back to my own empowerment and creates yet another opening for me to walk through. When I feel hopeless, she ignites hope within me and inspires me to unravel the ropes of my own hopelessness, trace it back to its origin, and rewrite my story..." and thought okay, I want me some of that can I book a session yesterday.

What about you Pinkies? How do you feel about Coaches? Does the term Coach make you cringe and remind you of standing against a brick wall for a game of dodgeball? Or... does it fill you with hope over all of the possibilities?  

Climbing with Joy,

Comments

Lissa Rankin's picture

I agree too

I certainly wasn't trying to dismiss therapists- in fact, I think they're fabulous and probably, everyone would be better off if we all had one!

And yes, Fred and Krista, because coaching is as yet unregulated, I'm sure there are a lot of unskilled people trying to pawn themselves off as coaches. The key is being humble and knowing when you're in over your head, which is what training programs and regulations can help with.

I too suspect things will trend that way...

n/a
Lissa Rankin's picture

Coaching vs Therapy

Krista, I agree with Fred. I very clearly tell coaching clients from the beginning that I am not a therapist (although as an MD, I had a great deal of training in psychiatry, including talk therapy, so if a session slips that way, I feel very comfortable). I do refer to therapists and I do specifically point out that, while I'm happy to listen to someone's story of their past in relation to how it applies to their future, coaching is not about fondling a story, working and reworking a past memory (not to dismiss the healing power of doing this in the right professional hands!). It's about looking at how the past informs the present and how we can let go of past wounds to focus on the next steps.

I hope that helps!

n/a
Krista Ross's picture

Yes, but...

There is of course tremendous overlap. It's a shallow caricature of therapy to suggest that all therapists do is help people dwell on the past. Good therapists do a lot of what both Lissa and Fred are describing in their coaching work. And you don't always know when someone walks in whether they have serious, longstanding issues that will need a different kind of expertise. I'm not worried about Lissa, who has plenty of training, but since coaches are not licensed or regulated, I do worry about some self-invented coaches who wouldn't necessarily know when they were getting out of their depth. In fact, I think that skill as a therapist OR a coach has a lot less to do with credentials than to do with natural empathy, (un)common sense, and a certain positive, hopeful attitude toward life. There are probably many coaches out there who do more good than many therapists with lots of letters after their names. I just worry about some of the newbies who aren't getting any support or supervision, and perhaps have a little more confidence than they should...

Fred Krazeise's picture

Couldn't agree with you more

Krista, I agree completely with you. There is tremendous overlap, and the very best therapists (and coaches) I know have the kind of natural empathy that you describe. My prediction is that the coaching profession will move towards a national certification program, much in the way that the massage therapy industry did in the early 1990s. It is only a matter of time (and I think that time is coming very soon) before states will regulate the practice of coaching. I believe we will definitely see regulations within the next 2-3 years.


Fred Krazeise's picture

Boundaries

Krista,

You raise a very good point about where the boundaries are set between coaching and more traditional forms of what I will broadly call "talk therapy." For me the boundaries are very clear:

Coaching is not therapy or counseling. Coaching is not about dealing with past issues – it’s about moving forward in the present. Coaching is not designed for people who are suffering with mental illness or severe clinical / chronic depression, and many coaches work hand-in-hand with therapists and counselors to ensure their clients receive proper care.

I have an extensive referral network of therapists with whom I work and refer clients to all the time. And I think this is true for most coaches. It is, at the end of the day, all about the client, and the coach, like any other responsible caregiver has to make sure that the clients needs are being met, first, foremost and always.

Fred


Krista Ross's picture

You nailed it

For me the term "coach" brings up my nemesis from grade school AND high school (the woman followed me as I went from one school to another!!), Mrs. Abbott. I was a chubby child, starting at age 7 or so, and I can still hear "Go You Chicken Fat Go!" echoing around the elementary school cafeteria/gym. I can still feel the humiliation of being smacked in the face with a dodgeball and being told to "rub it!" when you wanted to go see if your nose was broken. I was not a physically coordinated child -- I never got up the rope to the ceiling (no amount of humiliation would have made that possible), I never cleared the hurdles, or managed to do a cartwheel, or scored a goal in field hockey, and Mrs. Abbott was there through my entire childhood/ adolescence to make sure everyone noticed and to label it as "not trying". Arggh.

So yeah, "coach" has some bad vibes for me. I can't watch Glee -- Sue is just too scary. While the description of what coaching is attracts me very much, and goodness knows I could use someone like that in my life, I can't get past the name.

The other issue I have with coaching, from a totally different direction, is the question of boundaries with other professions. I was trained as a clinical psychologist, and while I don't practice anymore because I feel that such work should be left to people who don't suck at it, I still wonder how a coach draws the line between what they do and more intensive therapy. I know from working as a therapist that things can get serious pretty quickly when a client starts to really trust that they are safe with you -- and once you get into some really deep stuff it can be very hard to get out, or refer the client to someone else. I think part of feeling safe with a coaching relationship, for me, would be knowing that there are boundaries, and that the coach knows how to get me hooked up with a different kind of help if it looks like I need it. On the other hand, it would be important to know that they won't abandon or judge me if they start to think I'm too nuts for them -- that would feel terrible too.

So maybe one day, you all will come up with a better name, and/or I'll get over my heebie-jeebies. In the meantime, keep writing about what you really do, and who you are, and what you offer. The world needs you.

Melanie Bates's picture

Krista

I hear you sister on the past trauma. I think Fred has brilliantly answered the issue of boundaries. I also ADORE Lissa's term for "Coach". She is a "Change Catalyst" - that encompasses so much and takes my past memories out of the equation ;)

Melanie Bates's picture

Michelle,

I'm SO excited for you! Happy Birthday to you and, WOW, what a gift to self.

Lissa Rankin's picture

It's not about basketball

GREAT post Melanie! And no, it's really not about whistles, basketball, or Beulah.

I just got off the phone with a great coaching client, and it just reminded me that what I love about coaching is that it's not what happens when you talk to your best friend. Your best friend may be too enmeshed in keeping you stuck. She may want you to forever be her friend who always wanted to start a business but didn't or who wanted to lose weight but didn't or who wanted to find true love but didn't. It's not that your best friend doesn't love you- I'm sure she does- it's that most of us in regular life enable each other to be stuck. Change scares the hell out of most best friends, partners, or parents.

But witnessing and enabling positive change is like can can dancing for most coaches. We THRIVE on change, often because we've had to do the work ourselves and we know from personal experience how joyous it feels to get unstuck and start moving forward towards the lives we've always longed to live.

Now throw me that basketball!!!!
Big love
Lissa

n/a
Melanie Bates's picture

Lissa - Wow

Humdinger.... I hadn't really thought about best friends that way but I can see it so clearly in friendships in my own life. I know those friends love me but when it comes to my higher good there are just some who "don't have my back" so to speak. I'll throw you the basketball as long as we don't have to play H-O-R-S-E ;)

Joy Mazzola's picture

Thanks Mel

Word. Thank you for giving voice to us coaches who sometimes have trouble explaining that we're not Beulah. You nailed it. It's not about arse-kicking, motivational speeches, deafening encouragement, or any other form of get-up-and-go "woHOO"ness by which most of us are scarred from high school. It's presence, it's exploration, it's investigation. It is action, but actions that come from the deepest part of you (not done under threat or duress). We're space holders, not whistle blowers.

Personally, the term "coach" still makes ME cringe (damn that Jr. High ropes course), which isn't particularly handy at cocktail parties. It's not especially self-promoting when you visibly gag after stating your profession. But I haven't found a term that resonates more deeply with me, so I'm hoping that as awareness continues to spread thanks to fantabulous pieces like this one, we might eventually replace Beulah with a kinder, gentler poster child.

Reading this reminded me that I wrote a piece a few months ago trying to dispel the whistle myth ... http://www.owningpink.com/blogs/owning-pink/what-the-heck-life-coach

Thank you Mel. Phenomenal writing as always. xoo

Melanie Bates's picture

Awww...

Thank you Joy! I love what you wrote, "it's presence, it's exploration, it's investigation..." Sign me up for some of that too. And... yes, "a kinder, gentler poster child" is needed.

When you comment on an Owning Pink blog post, we invite you to be authentic and loving, to say what you feel, to hold sacred space so others feel heard, and to refrain from using hurtful or offensive language. Differing opinions are welcomed, but if you cannot express yourself in a respectful, caring manner, your comments will be deleted by the Owning Pink staff.