
The photo is of my daughter and me at the beach last summer; it is important to note that I am seriously sucking in the gut.
On Friday, this article about Barbie was brought to my attention. Apparently there is a new collector’s edition Barbie that is sporting a bit too much cleavage -- it's being marketed to adults but sold on the toy aisle next to all of the other Barbies. Mothers are up in arms that this doll is sending the wrong message to their young daughters. I looked at the photo of the doll and as a mother of two young daughters had... absolutely no reaction. For that reason I felt I had to write about it.
I have always been a body image obsessed woman. At different times in the past I have been a yoyo dieter, size 16 at my largest and size 4 at my smallest. Although I am healthy now, I’d secretly still love to be a 6 instead of the 10 that I am. I could blame my problem on the media or on Barbie, but I don’t really think that’s where it started. It started with the actual people in my life.
I grew up in a family of mostly overweight people. I listened to the women closest to me berate themselves for being fat, yet remind me to never ever call an overweight person fat. I watched the attention that my thin sister and her drop dead gorgeous bikini body received at the beach or the pool. Triple takes, not double takes. I soaked it all in like a sponge. Skinny equaled good. Fat, I mean “big”, equaled bad. Of course no one ever said this to me, but this is what their actions and reactions told me.
It wasn’t long before I was comparing myself to the real people around me. I remember how when I sat in those small chairs in elementary school, my “big” thighs spread out and filled the chair. I’d look at the girls around me and notice how their thighs didn’t. I’m sure it was at a very early age I started the practice that I still carry with me today… standing sideways in front of the mirror and sucking my tummy in. I can’t remember a time when I wasn’t obsessed with my weight. But I also can’t remember a time when I looked at a doll and believed that she was an actual representation of what I was supposed to look like.
It was the real people in my life that did this for me. The women who were fat -- *gasp* -- were terribly unhappy with their bodies. From that I learned that I needed to do anything possible to avoid getting fat. So I’ve dieted on and off from junior high on. Even this week I’ve “cut back” with the hopes to lose a few.
Despite the fact that I’m still more concerned with my body image than I’d like to be, one thing about me has changed. I never let my daughters know how much it matters to me because I do not wish the same fate on them. We discuss healthy choices in terms of food and exercise, but the emphasis is always on happiness and not vanity.
It boils down to this: if it matters to you, then it will matter to them. I know that if I beat myself up for eating the wrong foods, they are watching. If I make comments about my chubby tummy and stretch marks each time I change my clothes, they are listening. If I insist that the only way for me to be happy is with bigger boobs and smaller thighs, they are soaking it all in like sponges. I know because I’m still working on squeezing myself out!
I really believe that unless a little girl is taught otherwise, she will walk down the Barbie aisle and see a doll, nothing more…
What do you think, Pinkies? What is your reaction to seeing this well-endowed doll in the toy aisle? What is your relationship with your body image? What experiences in your childhood (and beyond) shaped the way you perceive, honor, and think about your body?
When you comment on an Owning Pink blog post, we invite you to be authentic and loving, to say what you feel, to hold sacred space so others feel heard, and to refrain from using hurtful or offensive language. Differing opinions are welcomed, but if you cannot express yourself in a respectful, caring manner, your comments will be deleted by the Owning Pink staff.
Comments
We learn best from our mothers!
By Lauren (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/17/2010 at 6:50 AMI have always been a believer that the first step to helping young girls love their bodies is to help their mothers love their bodies. Where else would we learn how to be so destructive and negative towards our bodies. As much as we want to attribute it to the media, it starts with the imprint our mothers gave us in regards to how they talked to and treated their bodies.
It is so refreshing to know that you are learning to love your own body through your desire to be an example for your daughters.
I've spoken to young girls, as young as 3rd grade who already know so much about what is considered an "acceptable
" body shape and a "pretty" body shape it is so disheartening.
I just know that when it starts with MOM, the media and others at school might play an influential role, but it's not the same. When our mother is happy in her body, we learn to be happy in our body inherently.
Thank you for posting this!
Body Image
By The Know It All Mom (not verified) on Monday, 08/16/2010 at 10:32 AMHello, and thanks for writing this. I share so many of your thoughts and experiences. I, too, grew up in a family with many overweight people and like you, "fat" was not a word we EVER used. I recently wrote about my own obsession with body image and my fear that I am passing this on to my daughter. If you care to, you can read it at: http://theknowitallmom.com/2010/05/my-body-image-my-daughter/. Hopefully our awareness of our own negative perceptions will help us to raise healthy, happy, well-adjusted daughters!
Awesome!!!
By Rebecca (not verified) on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 6:29 PMLeslie - Thanks for your post! There are so many things I love about what you wrote! While food and body issues are complex in their origin, what we model for our kids is a powerful anecdote to the forces within and in this world that define beauty and worth by the number on a scale. "If it matters to you, it will matter to them!" Amen, sister. I wish I could bottle up what you have and give it away to my clients for free. :-) I look forward to reading more of your posts in the future.
Thank you, Rebecca.
By Leslee Horner on Monday, 08/16/2010 at 4:14 AMFor this wonderful comment. I am glad that what I wrote spoke to you.
Love and Light,
Leslee
Visit my blog: Waiting for the Click
Don't just say it
By Ashley @ Nourishing the Soul (not verified) on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 3:08 PM"I never let my daughters know how much it matters to me because I do not wish the same fate on them."
I agree that we have to change our language and behaviors in order avoid passing along negative esteem issues to our children. I would go a step further, however, to say that we need to work through our own issues related to body image. I hear so often from mothers that they don't know why their daughters are struggling with eating or body image when they've worked so hard to keep what they say in check in front of them. The problem is that kids are brilliant and intuitive and simply not saying the words to them doesn't mean they don't pick up on all the clues about our feelings about our own bodies. We may think we're fooling them, but if we do we're only fooling ourselves. I believe that we can't teach something that we don't live, so we need to live and breathe positive body image and healthy living.
Good Reminder, Ashley
By Leslee Horner on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 4:05 PMYes, it is so very true. I am thankful for all the "inner work" I've done over the last several years that my issues are not the level they used to be. My husband even made a comment about my "cutting back to lose a few" statement in this post because really what I'm trying to do is treat my body with respect by not over-feeding it and filling it with unhealthy stuff. I want to live a long, happy, and active life. Learning to love all of me is part of that.
Love and Light,
Leslee
Visit my blog: Waiting for the Click
It might be true that if kids
By Melody (not verified) on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 11:07 AMIt might be true that if kids were raised without these sort of input they wouldn't be influenced by what Barbie is wearing.
Unfortunately, the reality is that most kids aren't as fortunate as yours and will emulate the Barbie. I sometimes cannot believe what 12 year olds are wearing! (And sometimes it's mature women who shock me as well!)
I really identified with your growing up exerience. I was born and bred in Buenos Aires, where being thin is everything and the rate of plastic surgeries is one of the highest in the world. Being a size 8-10, I was actually told by doctors that I was obese.
So yes, body image issues.. I got them! But I've learned to love my curves and my shape, and even the fact that I jiggle and have cellulite.
My body is healthy and it takes care of me. Paying attention to it's needs has transformed my relationship with it, and as a result, my relationship with the world.
Barbie's Always Had Big Boobs
By Kalisa (not verified) on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 10:44 AMWhen I got my first Barbie in the 70s, I was unpackaging her at our dining room table. My dad sat at the table and my mother stood next to me. When I pulled her out and began changing her clothes, my mom held up the naked doll to my dad. "Look at that," she said. "Have you ever seen a doll that looked like that??"
The fact that I still remember this snippet of a memory tells me that my take-away from this conversation was, "IT'S NOT REAL. REAL PEOPLE DON'T LOOK LIKE THAT."
It appears to me, from the photos, that all Matel has done is separate Barbie's gigantic plastic bust into two distinct breast. Yes, they gave her cleavage. Her proportions still resemble no true female figure (well okay...Pam Anderson, I guess) but at least it's a bit more realistic now.
Thankfully, my 17-year-old son doesn't have body issues. Then again, he's been thin since puberty (6'2 and about 160 lbs now). I often say I'm glad I didn't have a daughter b/c the body issues scare the bejezus out of me. Sounds like you're doing all the right things.
~k.
Barbie's Measurements
By Leslee Horner on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 11:12 AMIt seems like in the past they came up with Barbie's dimensions if she was in fact a real person and it was absolutely unachievable.
There is also the argument that the outfit this Barbie is wearing is too risque but I'd say the same about a lot of the outfits on the non-collector dolls. I really got a kick out of seeing the "Zoo Keeper Barbie" in super short shorts and a belly baring shirt. Last time I went to the zoo, I didn't see any of the employees dressed like that. But at the age my girls are at now, they wouldn't even notice those clothes as long as I didn't bring it to their attention.
I will admit though that in the past I have been quite critical of Bratz dolls but I think it was more of the "attitude" they portrayed than the image (although the image isn't exactly ideal).
Love and Light,
Leslee
Visit my blog: Waiting for the Click
Thank you...
By Leslee Horner on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 9:23 AMFor the great comments. I love the PBS ads that come on during the kids show that illustrate how whatever we do and however we act our kids are "recording" it. It is so important to love ourselves or at least "fake it til we make it" for the sake of our kids.
In college I had a friend who was a size 18 or bigger. I have to say though that she was one of the most body-confident women I have ever known. She loved her curves and didn't have any problems attracting men. She oozed sexual confidence. I don't remember ever once during our friendship hearing her call herself fat or make an outloud wish to lose weight. She was a breath of fresh air!
Love and Light,
Leslee
Visit my blog: Waiting for the Click
Me too!
By Claire Macaulay (not verified) on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 7:17 AMDear Leslee,
I have never liked my body and I have never really understood why. It has just never been quite good enough. I am a size 6 and have never been overweight, and like you I can't remember a time when I looked at pictures in a magazine or at celebrities and believed that they represented what I was supposed to look like either.
Your post has made me wonder if my feelings are related to my own upbringing, but I can't rememeber any particularly negative experiences there, however, I don't remember any positive ones either.
I have a young son and daughter and I desperately want to avoid burdening them with a negative body image. I try hard not to let them experience my own difficult relationship with my body,and they see me naked frequently. But perhaps avoiding the negative is not enough. Maybe, like many aspects of parenting, it needs to be positive reinforcement all the way.
And maybe in the process I will come to accept and respect my body just the way it is.
We influence our boys, too
By Suzanne Bouffard on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 6:08 AMTo second what Jennifer said, I think it's vitally important that we realize how our feelings and words about ourselves influence not just our daughters, but our sons. The things we say and do will influence their beliefs about how and who women should be - and that includes beliefs about how women look and behave in relation to their bodies.
Leslee, I am so impressed that you have managed to avoid saying negative things about yourself in front of your daughters. I hope I can do the same around my son. As with so many things, he's a great motivator. I wish that we could make these choices just for our own sake (because speaking these feelings out loud often reinforces them), but the additional motivation is certainly helpful - and certainly worth it!
Suzanne
walkin the walk!
By Jennifer Shelton on Sunday, 08/15/2010 at 4:07 AMYou deserve a standing ovation for loving and embracing your beautiful body!!!
I have a son, and haven't thought much about the body image message I send him but realize that I'm certainly influencing how he thinks about women and their appearance.
Thanks for another thought-provoking post. As is my introvert way, I'm certain additional comments will come to me at a later time!
Blessings,