
I have nothing good to say about depression. Depression has robbed my life of some very special people. Ten years ago I lost my best friend, Clay Whitmer, to suicide after years of depression. My father’s alcoholism -- rooted in depression -- robbed me of a loving father growing up. And then there is my mom. Eleven years ago, she died of heart disease. Huh? Yes, as CNN recently reported, a new study shows a link between heart disease and depression and gloomy personalities.
The researchers used a model called Type-D personality type to identify the high risk group. Type-D personalities are "characterized by negative emotions like anxiety, frustration, and anger, and at the same time score high on social inhibition, meaning that they are less likely to disclose emotions," according to one of the researchers. These individuals have an almost 4 times greater risk of a heart attack, heart failure death or other negative outcome, compared to heart patients with different personality profiles. Yicks.
We all know that diet and smoking increases our risk of heart disease, but now they are telling us our personality can put us at risk too? Wow. So I can eat my vegetables and do my yoga, but if I am a negative personality type, I am still at greater risk of heart disease. But how do I change my personality?
This is big news. Big enough and scary enough that I first had to ask if it even makes sense. And if so, what does a Type-D personality do to decrease their risk?
I was not surprised by these findings. My mother was depressed, suffered from low self-esteem, frequently frustrated and prone to pessimism; a borderline Type-D personality. She died at 53 of a heart attack after a decade of suffering from heart disease, type-II diabetes and an auto-immune disease. Her conditions further exacerbated her negative life outlook. She talked of amputations and wheelchairs in her future. Yet, she couldn't help herself. The dietary and exercise recommendations her doctors gave her were “too tough”. I would get upset when she would come home and only eat cereal for dinner because it was the easiest low-fat thing to eat. I would coach her (at her request) on how to prepare yummy meals. But she was so pessimistic and negative about her situation, and so depressed, that there was no amount of my coaching that was going to change matters. When a person is clinically depressed it is nearly impossible to make the necessary lifestyle changes, at least without some kind of professional intervention. So depression or a gloomy personality contribute to heart disease? Yes -- at least my experience certainly confirms the research results.
In contemplating this new research, I was reminded of the story of Dean Ornish as an undergraduate student. In Blessings in Disguise, he shares his own story of depression as a college freshman and how he contemplated and even began preparing for suicide. Dr. Dean Ornish went on to conduct comprehensive research and develop a protocol shown to reverse heart disease. That protocol, referred to as the Spectrum Program, focuses on lifestyle changes related to diet, exercise and stress management in the form of meditation and yoga and other techniques also known to help alleviate depression. Not exactly a coincidence.
So Dr. Ornish has shown us that heart disease can be prevented. But this new research is a wake up call. Some individuals may need more than meditation and yoga. Having suffered from two bouts of depression myself, witnessing the depression of those around me, and adjusting to the realities of my own health issues, I can tell you that getting rid of depression takes more than lifestyle change.
The good news about this new study is that Type-D personalities (whether clinically depressed or not), can now be targeted as an at-risk group. In addition to diet, exercise and stress management, we may find these individuals benefit from therapy. There are many types of therapies, and if you are depressed or you believe you are a Type-D personality, I strongly encourage you to seek help. Being depressed, angry and frustrated is no way to go through life. And as we have now confirmed, it can also kill you.
I know some people are hesitant or embarrassed about being in therapy. As someone who has spent almost ten non-consecutive years in therapy, I say “don’t be.” It is much less embarrassing to spill your guts to a therapist than cry all the way home on the bus every night. Trust me on this!
I was hesitant to try therapy during my first bout with depression. In fact, my first therapist was a dud. But I was feeling too awful to give up. A few more tries and I finally found someone I could connect with. That professional helped me get through my sophomore year in college in tact.
I have gone back to therapy at different stages in my life. Whether dealing with a full-blown case of clinical depression in my thirties, or being diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in my forties, I have turned to therapists to help me through tough and confusing times. Some periods of therapy took longer than others, but in each case I found peace with who I am and my circumstances. My stress levels were reduced. I found joy. And now, I see that I might have even been saving my life.
If you are at-risk according to this new research, please seek help. It could be the single most important gift you give yourself!
Has heart disease touched your life? Have you see a connection between a Type-D personality and heart disease in your life? Are you a Type-D personality? What do you think of this study? Will you do anything to change your personality?
I used to be Type-A. But over the last year have become a solid B. Have you changed your personality type? If so, tell us how.
In healthy community,
When you comment on an Owning Pink blog post, we invite you to be authentic and loving, to say what you feel, to hold sacred space so others feel heard, and to refrain from using hurtful or offensive language. Differing opinions are welcomed, but if you cannot express yourself in a respectful, caring manner, your comments will be deleted by the Owning Pink staff.
Comments
I like this quote, La via
By Zoorceped (not verified) on Wednesday, 10/20/2010 at 12:12 AMI like this quote, La via esta duro, amigo.
I realized the post would go
By Cosmetic Surgery Europe (not verified) on Wednesday, 09/22/2010 at 3:13 AMI realized the post would go on forever. But now I see that maybe another post on that subject would be helpful. I do know however that it is a tough one for me to tackle because of my own experience with depression. Of course, that might make all the more important to write. Thank you for sharing your story.
Life cocktail experiments
By Dana Theus on Saturday, 09/18/2010 at 5:46 AMFred, I love this idea. I guess that's very much how I've approached my own health. Though as Laurie writes about, for the longest time I just focused on my mental health. It's only been recently I've begun to see the connections between physical and mental and spiritual health. Some of that is because i've been blessed with a very healthy body so it never squeaked at me to look at it until "old" age began to make itself known. But it does continue to surprise me how connected our whole beings are. The more spiritually aware I become, the more I notice how my body affects my awareness. I've always been a little derisive of those who are "so sensitive" to physical extremes (like lack of sleep, overabundance of sugar etc) and now I can see myself becoming more sensitive. And my treatment is to swizzle the cocktail a bit here and there and adjust. The radical approach - which I totally respect Laurie and others who go there - just hasn't worked for me so far because I end up radically swinging in both directions and just end up on a yoyo. I can see circumstances where that probably wouldn't happen to me so much (maybe when my kids go to college and my house isn't stocked with foods that their bodies devour and mine find poisonous?) Anyway, we're each individual beings and it makes total sense that we each need our own kind of Life Cocktail. Thanks for that great analogy!
Life Cocktail Mixology
By Fred (not verified) on Saturday, 09/18/2010 at 6:24 AMDear Dana,
Of couse you only recently saw the connection, because Western medicine (not meaning to bash, but it is a convenient target) seeks to dissect rather than construct. It breaks the body down into its' components, rather than seeing humans as the sum of our parts.
We've all been conditioned to think that if you have a physical ailment, you see a doctor (this is made even worse now because of over-specialiation - You need to see a heart doctor, a skin doctor, a left elbow doctor, a right elbow doctor, etc.). If you have a mental issue, you see a therapist or counselor. If you have a crisis of spirit, you seek out your priest, minister, rabbi, shaman, kahuna, or whatever. But all of these elements are connected.
There is an undeniable, inextricable link between our physical, emotional, and spiritual selves. Western medicine is only very recently acknowledging that link, and it usually happens in cases where the patient is terminal. "You've exhausted all of my treatment options, so I'd advise you to pray," says the doctor.
You are absolutely correct when you say that we are all different, and the ingredients of what goes into our life cocktail have to take that into account.
Peace,
Fred
Thanks for sharing
By Laurie Erdman on Saturday, 09/18/2010 at 3:37 AMyour stories and thoughts.
Fred and Stacey, I really like your "life-cocktail" idea. Yes, life is a celebration and we should all drink in those things which make it more fun and fulfilling. For me, I love the "radical self care" because unfortunately self-care is radical for most people. And you are so right that it is not just one thing - but a combination of modes of healing and prevention that keep us available for being the loving beings we are.
Jennifer, I can very much relate to your situation. Although my mother did know about my therapy, she mostly concerned about what I was saying about her and what "she had done wrong as a mother." Not very helpful for either of us. I thought about addressing those - like your family and so many others I know - that don't "believe" in talk-therapy. But as I did, I realized the post would go on forever. But now I see that maybe another post on that subject would be helpful. I do know however that it is a tough one for me to tackle because of my own experience with depression. Of course, that might make all the more important to write. Thank you for sharing your story.
Dana - I like Type-P personality. I think there is a blog post in that somewhere. What exactly is it and how can one achieve it? I think for those of us participating here and in the community we are striving for it.
With love and light to all,
Laurie Erdman
Chronic Wellness Coaching: Empowering You to Heal Your Body, Mind and Spirit
Thanks for sharing
By Laurie Erdman on Saturday, 09/18/2010 at 3:36 AMyour stories and thoughts.
Fred and Stacey, I really like your "life-cocktail" idea. Yes, life is a celebration and we should all drink in those things which make it more fun and fulfilling. For me, I love the "radical self care" because unfortunately self-care is radical for most people. And you are so right that it is not just one thing - but a combination of modes of healing and prevention that keep us available for being the loving beings we are.
Jennifer, I can very much relate to your situation. Although my mother did know about my therapy, she mostly concerned about what I was saying about her and what "she had done wrong as a mother." Not very helpful for either of us. I thought about addressing those - like your family and so many others I know - that don't "believe" in talk-therapy. But as I did, I realized the post would go on forever. But now I see that maybe another post on that subject would be helpful. I do know however that it is a tough one for me to tackle because of my own experience with depression. Of course, that might make all the more important to write. Thank you for sharing your story.
Dana - I like Type-P personality. I think there is a blog post in that somewhere. What exactly is it and how can one achieve it? I think for those of us participating here and in the community we are striving for it.
With love and light to all,
Laurie Erdman
Chronic Wellness Coaching: Empowering You to Heal Your Body, Mind and Spirit
Mixing a Life Cocktail
By Fred (not verified) on Saturday, 09/18/2010 at 5:35 AMThe notion of developing a "life cocktail" came to me when working with clients suffering from Fibromyalgia. I have many clients with fibromyalgia who come to me for bodywork, and they all profess a desire to be less dependent on medication. So, we work up a wellness plan that includes exercise, nutrition, mindfulness and meditative practice, regular bodywork and energy work. We test things and keep the things that work, and throw away the things that don't. We add these "life cocktail" ingredients to their daily routine, and make adjustments along the way until the client is leading the kind of lifestyle she is satisfied with. The coach acts as a kind of advocate and helps the client set and maintain goals.
Sadly, this is not the kind of care that traditional medicine is equipped to deliver. It requires an investment of time on the part of both the client and the coach. And in our "transaction-based" healthcare system, doctors are limited to seeing patients for very brief periods of time. And there is rarely any follow up. I can tell you that I spend hours with clients, both during their session and afterwards, checking in and helping them practice the rigorous self-care that you describe.
At the end of the day, what it requires is a commitment on the part of the client and to a lesser extent the caregiver. I cannot "will" good health to my clients. But if they are determined to make sustainable change in their life, I am committed to do everything I can to help them lead a complete and rich existence and to enjoy the full bounty that life has to offer.
Peace,
Fred
Type D & Depression
By Bronwyn (not verified) on Friday, 09/17/2010 at 10:20 PMWhat a fantastic article Laurie. The more information we can get into the public domain about the realities of managing depression and our emotional health and wellbeing, the better our world will be.
We have a national scheme in Australia, whereby people can request a mental health assessment plan through the medicare system. I encourage clients to do their research and identify a professional they feel they would respond to,then go to their doctor and request a referral to the professional of their choice. This can all be arranged as a no fee for service 12 month plan, whereby on review the client and professional decide whether further support is required.
My family biology includes diabetes, alcoholism, obesity and genetic depression, just to mention a few. I choose to seek help as a proactive and preventative measure and encourage people to do the same.
Thanks again for writing this Laurie. Blessings my friend :) xx
Type P
By Dana Theus on Friday, 09/17/2010 at 7:54 PMIs it possible to be a Type A-? I'm shooting for Type P(ink). Thanks for the interesting and educational article. My brushes with depression taught me it's a serious condition and we need to do whatever it takes to break out of it. For each of us, that is something different, but all the strategies you mention have worked for me, too.
Rx: Life Cocktail
By Stacey Curnow on Friday, 09/17/2010 at 6:25 AMHi Laurie,
Thanks so much for sharing these fascinating studies and your inspiring story! I'm so grateful we have a better understanding of the mind/body connection and we've learned how to concoct "life cocktails" that truly take this into account. Thanks again, and much love, s
Stacey is a nurse-midwife and life coach who helps you give birth to your BIG dreams- check out her FREE Purpose and Passsion Guidebook
There is no "one" thing
By Fred (not verified) on Friday, 09/17/2010 at 5:52 AMYou have highlighted the importance of a kind of 360 degree view of a patient. It's so important to pull together many modes of treatment, from medication, coaching, meditation, exercise, and yes, talk-therapy. I call this creating a "life-cocktail," where we identify the ingredients and the measurements required of each of these modalities. The real challenge in our healthcare system is that very few practitioners take a 360 degree approach. The challenge then falls to the patient / client, and she (as in the case of your mother), may not have the energy, skills to meet it.
This is an excellent article Laurie. Thank you so much for sharing.
Peace,
Fred
the majority of my family members
By Jennifer Shelton on Friday, 09/17/2010 at 5:43 AMYes! In the past ten years my father has had two open heart surgeries, 8 by-passes, one heart valve replacement, and he currently has 8 stents. He is in the hospital roughly every 3-6 mos with more heart pain. Two years ago, when the DRs where putting in a stent, the plague exploded and went through his system. He died on the table BUT was brought back by paddle shocks. TWELVE PADDLE SHOCKS. He had horrible burns on his chest but he walked out of the hospital just 5 days later! He's currently got a fresh round of chest pain that just started a few days ago. Other than his heart, he's very healthy. I guess that (and his stubbornness) has kept him going. Oh, and I wonder if he was the proto-type for the "Type D" article...I know he's been involved in a study or two, including one ongoing one on psychology. He certainly fits the profile. Heck, he IS the profile.
Then, there's my mother's side of the family. My maternal grandmother has had two open hearts and several heart attacks (she's 90 now). At last count, she knows of 28 of her relatives who've had open heart. That's not counting relatives who have died of heart attacks.
I have been through therapy, although no one in my family, except my sister, knows it. My family believes that therapy is ridiculous and that it's dangerous to tell people about your feelings. In fact, in their view, it's not wise to acknowledge or express feelings at all. I think I just validated the article!
Thanks for writing this, Laurie. Here's to years of healthy hearts!
Blessings,