
They say dating is dead; hookups are all the rage. So I went straight to my beautician, the local dating expert, to see if this was true. Her answer was grave, “I don’t know where a girl goes these days to find a guy who actually wants to build a relationship. Maybe online dating?” Poor Ashley sounds tired for 26. “What’s wrong with the men of my generation? They’re terrified of commitment.”
Pass the pork and bless the beans! I’m 19 years out of the singles market and yet, I’m still not free of it. My two children are on the cusp of sexual curiosity and, being their mother, I suppose it’s up to me to prepare them for the dating scene AS IT IS. Could Ashley be right, are men afraid of commitment?
“Why does Rihanna keep saying S…S…S…M…M…M?” my 11-year-old daughter asks in her evaporating innocence. Holy Crap! I was prepared when the sex talk came at seven but I never imagined I’d be hashing over S&M with her in the family minivan. Thanks Rihanna, thanks a bunch!!
I debate playing “naïve” because, honestly, I’m not ready to explain to my child that some people like to mix pain with sex. “I’m going to tell all my friends at school how much I love that song.” She chimes. Great! Now I have this mental image of her telling her girlfriends how much she likes S&M, which will travel through the 5th grade faster than headlice until some wiseass boy asks her if she’d like to bend over so he can spank her. HOLY CRAP!!! I’m taking a baseball bat to our stereo tonight.
I should swallow my mortification and open myself up to preparing her for this trend toward empty sex. “I don’t have time for a boyfriend,” Sara, my 20-year-old neighbor admits. “I’m too busy focusing on my degree and I’ve got to be ready to go wherever it takes me. That’s what the dudes have been doing all this time.” Ahhh… Sara’s voice sparks my growing suspicion. Could the popularity of the hookup be correlated to the growing rise in female independence? Maybe it’s not the dudes driving this trend but today’s modern woman…maybe it’s us.
Let’s face it, men have proven pretty willing to follow our lead when it comes to sex. When women were demanding a two-year wooing process, men were doing it. Now that we’re accepting a quick sext (sex+text), men are doing it. If the women of America took a sexual stand tomorrow, demanding an extensive string of gourmet cooking classes, candlelit chats, and salsa dancing MEN WOULD BE DOING IT.
...this is an offshoot of feminism. Maybe western women love the fact that we can screw a stranger without any fear of tying ourselves to them for life. Maybe we’re finally meeting our own sexual needs as efficiently as we are meeting our mortgage payments. Now that more of us are running our own show, we’re free to test our own sexual grounds, own sex on our own terms, and redefine normal. Has sexual liberation finally reached the bedroom?
But where does all this take my parental wisdom? I want my daughter to KNOW she is completely capable of doing anything she wants on her own. I want her to be comfortable and confident in her sexuality and her feminine energy. If a string of hookups is going to validate this for her, empower her, then who am I, with all my Sweet Valley High dreams, to lace it with guilt and judgment?
And where does this leave my son? I’ve never been one of those “boys will be boys” type of moms but am I truly preparing him for the dating world with statements like “Most girls have a hard time keeping their hearts out of the sex” or “A guy becomes part of a girl once he’s inside of her body.” Am I going to raise a sensitive, hesitant man who will find himself repeatedly bagged and abandoned? Maybe I should be preparing him for women with strong, independent minds, significant resources, and very little time; like 12 hours.
I can continue to raise them to value relationships even as they explore and thrive in their mutual independence. Because I want both of them to know that life-changing lessons rarely come in a 3 hour shack session, that a life without intimate connection can become a very lonely place. I want my daughter to know the joy of having a mate who supports and celebrates her efforts because they were around to witness her struggles. I want my son to know it’s okay to make himself vulnerable to another in the name of love, that he will not only survive, but will be a better man for it. I want them to experience the magic of making love. I want them to understand how a loving partner acts as our reflecting pool; displaying our greatest gifts while they challenge our weaknesses. Relationships nurture us. Push us. Teach us when to serve, sacrifice, and choose ourselves first. I want my children to create heart wrenching moments with another person whose very name will chime in their hearts like the sweetest bell. Moments that will light up their death bed like fireflies over a summer lake.
...a hookup will feed their sense of independence but I still believe it’s the relationships that will feed their souls.
What about you? Are you trying to prepare you children for a dating world you don’t understand? Do you feel the value of relationships is being undermined by the demand for a quick physical release? Does feminism have anything to do with this trend? Or do you think I’ve been listening to too many hours of Rihanna and I should follow through on taking a bat to my stereo?
Monica Wilcox
When you comment on an Owning Pink blog post, we invite you to be authentic and loving, to say what you feel, to hold sacred space so others feel heard, and to refrain from using hurtful or offensive language. Differing opinions are welcomed, but if you cannot express yourself in a respectful, caring manner, your comments will be deleted by the Owning Pink staff.
Comments
Thanks, Monica (& commenters!)
By Rachel A (not verified) on Saturday, 08/20/2011 at 12:44 PMMonica,
As mom of two boys (13 & 16 (on 8/29), as well as a woman who's been through many phases of sexual and/or emotional relationships, I really appreciate this post! And all of the comments, too. Thank you!!
Your Welcome
By Monica Wilcox on Saturday, 08/20/2011 at 6:38 PMGlad you liked it Rachel! My guess is that you've dealt with this topic in your home a few times too. :)
Keep on communicating!!
Monica
Monica Wilcox
www.femmetales.com
Hook ups vs. Stick Arounds
By JJ (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 10:51 PMWhile I would land with the philosophy that a lot of sexual exploration can actually damage the ability to be fulfilled in a relationship (see studies published in the last year claiming varied sexual partners lead to decreased satisfaction in relationships), I do think there are some excellent points in this article.
Going back to ancient Greek times and Lysistrata, *women* tend to pull the strings when it comes to sexuality. When we choose to believe men are not interested in commitment and not capable of being monogamous we enable men to lower their standards and treat women as "less than."
I love that feminism has freed women to step out of the cookie cutters... but I hate that it has made women who genuine *want* the traditional life feel like they're missing something....
The most important thing to teach your kids, in my opinion, is to value other humans and love them *despite*; despite their faults, despite their success, despite their ambition... to genuinely love, sacrifice and offer grace in relationships, even when it's hard.
That's my two cents... :) Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Being 19, I can relate from
By Arpita (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 4:27 PMBeing 19, I can relate from the other end. The idea of a 2-year-long waiting period of impressive romance before sex sounds exhausting. If I met a man interested in that, I wouldn't invest energy into the relationship. In this phase of my life I'm growing and learning at lightning speed. I'm wanting quick, intense interactions with many people to learn about myself, about sex, about emotions, about what I want. I don't want to be tied down to one person's perceptions of me. That wouldn't give me enough space to expand. On the other hand, I have my need for intimacy being met by a stable support net of long-term loving friends. Not every woman has that. I imagine being promiscuous without intimate friends would be hell. I sense my phase of quick sexual interactions coming to an end relatively soon. Once I have more of a clear idea of who I am, I'll want to invest in a long-term sexual relationship with one person (of course not just sexual - emotional intimacy and safety is a requirement I have for anyone I bring into my life). Anyway, I see why you're worried. My mom is worried when I tell her about my explorations. Sometimes I think she wishes I was less open with her. But I want her to know that she can trust me as much as I trust myself. Something I'd like to remember when I'm a mom is that kids are trustworthy. They are divine beings just like everyone else. They'll take on just as much struggle as is appropriate for them. It may seem like worrying is a normal and good way to support kids but my experience is that a worrying parent alienates. I would rather focus on learning about my kids' world - why do they like the things they like? What need is being met? What values are behind their actions? Although as an adolescent they may seem out of control, they are still being guided by their higher selves through the turmoil they need. They're competent somewhere in there. Thank you for the article. Really great to have the parental perspective. :) Love and Light, Arpita
Beautiful
By Michelle Wallace (not verified) on Wednesday, 08/17/2011 at 5:45 AMI very much loved your comment. I'm 31 and a single mom of a 4 yr old. And I have to say that I really do think you'll make a great mom someday, if you choose that path to partake :)
Michelle
Wisdom from the Dating Field
By Monica Wilcox on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 8:08 PMThanks Arpita for sharing with us how it is for you in the dating field. I agree, worrying is an utter waste of energy and will only push my kids away instead of bring them closer. But I do try to get a grasp on the world they are headed for since it's my privilege to prepare them for it. Sometimes this can be difficult for a parent when we don't relate. Like Lissa, I've never experienced anything close to a hook-up. My heart always had to be involved. But I also know this is not the case for every woman and may not be the case for my daughter.
I appreciate your perspective and insight!! Keep on expanding!! Monica
Monica Wilcox
www.femmetales.com
LOVE this post, Monica!
By Lissa Rankin on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 3:54 PMOh my- you took the words right out of my mouth! (By the way, my 5 year old also asked me about Rihanna's song!)
What a fabulous article.
As someone who has never ever in my entire life "hooked up" I honestly can't relate to this concept. I went through a phase where I thought maybe I should try random hook ups, that maybe I was missing something vital and empowering by not doing so.
I've always been quick to go deep. In fact, I joke that I don't put out on the first date, and if you get a second date, I'll probably marry you.
But in truth, the whole concept of random hook ups has just never appealed to me.
If hook ups for women are empowering, then I think I agree with my friend Nicole Daedone. Maybe we've empowered ourselves out of our own surrender, when in truth, what every man wants is a woman who is putty in their hands and what every woman wants is a man who wants to make art with her putty.
I don't know. It's complicated.
But such a great topic to consider.
Thank you!
Big love
Lissa
Can SO Relate!!
By Monica Wilcox on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 8:22 PMI was never one for random hook ups either, Lissa. I think that's part of why I'm struggling with all of this as a mother. It's difficult to relate to a trend when you can't emotionally connect to it, Should be interesting to see where western women take romantic relationships in the next few decades.
Love Nicole's comment. She may be onto something.
Many blessings and great parental wisdom!!!
Monica
Monica Wilcox
www.femmetales.com
S&M Does Not Equal Empty Sex
By April Cooper (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 9:06 AMWhile I appreciate this article, have some of the same concerns about my kids and hook-up culture, and agree that it's tough to have to explain S&M to a pre-teen because of a pop song, as someone who has explored BDSM within deeply intimate relationships and as a method of profound psycho-spiritual healing, I don't appreciate the implication that S&M is empty sex. It furthers the negative view of BDSM among those who simply don't understand it.
BDSM often leads to deeper intimacy between people rather than empty interactions, just by the nature of playing within power dynamics and challenging ourselves physically and emotionally. A safe BDSM scene includes emotional safety, which requires a sort of emotional intimacy that casual sex does not. Of course there are people who have casual BDSM interactions, but in my experience there is most often real friendship and intimacy at the core of even casual play. You just can't go to those intense places safely without it.
In regards to raising our children with a sex positive mindset, just like many children know they are gay or trans at an early age (my son came out as gay when he was 11), I know many people who practice BDSM who started exhibiting tendencies for bondage, sadism and masochism at very early ages. In fact, I recently discovered my own 15 year old daughter has been cutting as a way to manage her emotional world. We are now talking about healthy ways of channelling her intense emotions, which includes using the body to release emotion without causing harm to herself (yoga, dancing, etc.). Because of my own experience with managing my emotional world through physical masochism (an intense scene allows me to release a lot of stress and emotion stuck in my body), I am able to both empathize with and support her rather than freak out at her behavior (and yes, I also have her seeing a therapist).
As my children have moved through their teen years, they have learned a little bit about BDSM. They don't know what I do or how I do it. But they know it exists and they know that lots of people they care about within our community participate in such activities. They know they can ask questions without fear of judgment or other negative consequences.
I know it's scary to consider exposing our kids to ideas that are challenging even to us, but the reality is some of us are just wired this way, and growing up knowing that we're normal and lovable just as we are is vital to growing up healthy and whole.
Thank you for your consideration, April
Agreed
By Michelle Wallace (not verified) on Wednesday, 08/17/2011 at 5:39 AMApril, I happen to very much agree with you. I think that the difficulty with explaining 'S&M' to a child because it's in a popular song, is just that, it's in a popular song. I remember when 'Like a Virgin' came out. How taboo it was to have the word 'virgin' in the title... Only 25 years ago, it was easy to screen what your child was watching because there was only The Cosby Show and Full House on cable. Now, there is no way around trying to explain complex sexual concepts to our children. So I think the best way is to explain it the best way we can. And with the openness about sexuality that our society is now heading.
Cheers!
Michelle
Shallow Sex
By Monica Wilcox on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 3:47 PMThe beautiful thing about OP is that we consider everyone's point of view as long as it does not attack someone else. Thank you for your clarity and honesty around BDSM.
I'm sorry, April, if my post lead you to believe I think all S&M relationships are empty ones. Honestly, I would not know. But I would imagine they are the same as every other human interaction; they can be shallow or highly connective. My concern is that our culture may be too quick to put our focus on meaningless, physical sex. It feels good, it's easy, it's quick, and most of us love anything that fulfills these requirements. :) But relationships are where the real connection, and growth, happens. This requires energy, time, nurturing and effort. I'm curious if we are loosing long term romantic connections because women are putting all of their energy into THEIR lives: an education, career, home. Maybe. If so, where does that leave the next generation? Should I prepare my children for intimate, long term relationships? Would it be the same as my mother preparing me for a 2 year courting period? As you've pointed out, relationships are always better when intimacy and trust are involved. The question is do we still value this as a society, no matter what sexual practice we may prefer?
Monica Wilcox
www.femmetales.com
So Agree
By Monica Wilcox on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 8:42 AM"The romantic relationship, now in 2011, is only a part of the whole, rather than the whole." LOVE your comment Michelle. And in the end, this is what I want for my daughter and son: a strong independent life filled with many loving, supportive relationships.
Great response!!
Monica Wilcox
www.femmetales.com
YAY!!
By Michelle Wallace (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/16/2011 at 7:23 AMI love your post! Fantastic writing. I do agree that it is the independent woman who no longer has the time to chase after a romantic relationship that is fueling this change. However. These are the same women who are making careers, becoming independent and aren't the stereotype of a needy, nagging housewife either. They are the women who, when they love, they love because the want to, not because they need to. And these are the women who follow their careers, travel to the 4 corners of the world and back home again with stories of wonder and enchantment they wouldn't have gotten if they had stayed at home afraid to spend theirs & their partner's money. These are the women who build relationships of all types. It is true that it's relationships that make life more meaningful and beautiful. But I think that it's very important for a girl to know how to nurture other, just as beautiful, relationships. The 'romantic relationship', now in 2011, is only a part of the whole, rather than the whole.