Owning Pink Bloggers

Seek ways to express your creativity. It helps you see the world in a whole new way.

A Life Ripe With Choices - How Do We Decide?

Melanie Bates's picture

My life is ripe with choices. Some of these choices are fat on the vine: juicy, sun-kissed, and just waiting for me to reach out and pluck them. These maturated choices are easy – shall I have chicken and rice for dinner, or that container of cream cheese frosting? They are also often just plain obvious – should I stay up until 4:30 a.m. reading The Hunger Games, or should I try to get some sleep? (The answer is to read, of course. The answer is always to read.) 

Many choices are not quite ripened and seem completely out of reach. In fact, these harder nuggets make their home on a branch that stretches right over the edge of a cliff. To pick these little suckers would require my taking a major pleap (Pink leap of faith) while uttering a prayer that, when I land, the thing will still be held tightly in my grasp. These greener choices are often difficult: should I apply for a master’s degree, or just plant my rump in a chair and finish my novel? Lastly there are the choices that have turned to a rather grainy mush under my feet and stained my toes permanently purple; these little gobs are pretty hard to salvage.

My personal demi-god

It’s the more difficult choices dangling in front of me that keep me up at night (well, that and the twelve glasses of iced tea I’ve consumed throughout the day). For example, this master’s degree decision has me twisted and perplexed and I’d like nothing more than to have the ability to email God. Instead I’ve seeked guidance from the next best person: a publisher.

About a week or so ago I was on an #askYAed chat on Twitter and, while I’m somewhat new to the Twitterverse, I have managed to follow agents, authors, publishers, and editors so that I may hang on their every word. I had never spoken up in any of these “ask editor” chats but somehow I felt compelled to ask the professionals whether they thought I should go for the master’s or write. The wonderful Elizabeth Law answered me, and as I read her words I imagined the beams of brilliant light shining forth from her head and a Gregorian chant playing in the background. After I detached myself from the 15 foot beam on my ceiling and was able to stop chanting, “A publisher just spoke to me! A publisher just spoke to me!”  I read her response and burned it forever into my brain. Ms. Law said, “You’re wrestling with a big question.  Look into your heart, what do you want to do, what’s right for you...” 

What does my heart want to do? My heart wants to write -- my soul, my fingers, every part of me. But as Elizabeth (may I call her by her first name? -faints-) pointed out, “If you were pursuing a master’s in creative writing, wouldn’t that keep your ass in the chair? Wouldn’t you be writing?” I didn’t have a concrete answer yet but, due to this beautiful advice from a demi-god, I had at least stopped to look into my heart.

Ask and the serendipity follows

The next day I visited Owning Pink and by hell if Pinkie Dana Theus hadn’t written an article called “Mojo: What Gives You MOre JOy?” Wow! What brings me joy? (Sometimes I’m not sure if that’s joy I’m feeling, or too much caffeine.) In regards to the master’s decision I just don’t know. I definitely feel joyful when I’m in school, though writing academic essays makes me want to vomit large chunks the size of grapefruits out of my nostrils. Writing, on the other hand, brings me a joy I experience with nothing else. It seems simple then, to make the decision to just write, but as Elizabeth Law said, I can write while I’m in a program. In fact it would sort of be my job to plant my arse every day. I could receive invaluable knowledge in a creative writing program.

At this point I’m no closer to a decision but at least now I’m rooting around in my heart, tossing aside rubbish, and thinking about what brings me MOre JOy.   

It’s just a fantasy

I decided to at least look into some master’s programs and I wasn’t particularly filled with glee over what I found. Most programs won’t accept writers of young adult fantasy. In fact, I think it’s safe to say that 99% of these programs are looking for writers of literary fiction and they tend to “look down” upon writers of “popular fiction.” I love me some literary fiction, I get it, but the story that’s been ricocheting around in my head and taken up residence in my heart is a work of fantasy. However, I did find two programs that have tracks for “popular fiction.”  Hmmm… do I want my fiction to be popular, or would I rather write a literary work that’s called “edgy” by six people in the English department at Nob University? (Hint: This is one of those easy choices.) Besides, there are great fantasy writers out there whose work I consider to be literary. Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy is a literary work of genius and, in my humble opinion, just happens to contain elements of fantasy.    

Shaking things up

Figuring out the college stuff also begs the question, where do I want to plant myself in this chair of mine. England, studying under the Master Pullman? Ireland, an amazing setting for a fantasy writer? Then I thought that perhaps San Francisco is the right place for me. Two of my closest friends live there. Owning Pink, and what it stands for, makes its home there.  Nah, I thought, I don’t want to live in California, too many earthquakes.

Well, so much for that reasoning. It’s as if God were sitting up there in His massive black leather recliner, looking like an ethereal Jean Luc Picard, the arm of His chair covered by a panel of green buttons and red knobs which control everything from sprouting daffodils to major weather changes. He chuckled and lifted the glass case on a shiny orange lever and pulled it forward and as I sat at my desk in Ohio... the room began to shake. Someone in Ottawa must have needed a bigger jolt than I because a 5.0 magnitude earthquake started there and traveled over five hundred miles at fourteen thousand miles per hour to let me know that California isn’t the only place where I’d experience earthquakes. As I sat there, the door swaying, the earth literally moving under my feet, I felt connected to our Mother as she grumbled, adjusted, and shifted Herself, getting more comfortable as she knitted a string of daisies and tulips. 

I relate to Her, I just don’t know where to shift myself and where I’d be more comfortable. Plus, I can’t knit.

Ah Pinkies... what would you do? How do you make these big decisions when you’ve heard/felt so many signs and received such amazing advice but you’re still unsure? What are the juicy decisions you’re currently grappling with? Do you have any of these hard green choices to make?

Comments

Suzanne Bouffard's picture

Questions and options

Melanie,
These are such touch choices. But you're halfway there, because you know what your goal is - to write as much as possible. So now (it seems to me) a big question is - what will most allow me to do that? This opens up a bunch of other questions that might guide you. Do you do more or better writing when you have structure and assignments, or when you have open time and freedom? Do you need contacts in the field and will an MFA help you get them or not? Etc. (I have a friend who is a TV writer who made so many great contacts in grad school that it was totally worth the time and money.)

Another thought: can you find a program that's really tailored to your interests? Lesley University in Cambridge, MA has a creative writing program with a concentration in writing for young people. There are probably other programs like this, too. (You might look at places like Lesley that have a focus on education or child development.)

Good luck!

Suzanne

Suzanne Bouffard's picture

Questions and options

Melanie,
These are such touch choices. But you're halfway there, because you know what your goal is - to write as much as possible. So now (it seems to me) a big question is - what will most allow me to do that? This opens up a bunch of other questions that might guide you. Do you do more or better writing when you have structure and assignments, or when you have open time and freedom? Do you need contacts in the field and will an MFA help you get them or not? Etc. (I have a friend who is a TV writer who made so many great contacts in grad school that it was totally worth the time and money.)

Another thought: can you find a program that's really tailored to your interests? Lesley University in Cambridge, MA has a creative writing program with a concentration in writing for young people. There are probably other programs like this, too. (You might look at places like Lesley that have a focus on education or child development.)

Good luck!

Suzanne

Melanie Bates's picture

Suzanne

I think you've hit upon a bit of my fear (which is a great thing.) When I think about what will allow me to write it sometimes makes me feel stuck. I remember working 8-5 type jobs and having no energy, whatsoever, to plant my ass in the chair. So, in that regard, a master's seems like ideal writing time. But... I don't want to make a decision based on fear, especially such a big and costly decision. That might be my biggest problem really, is that I'm like a tennis ball bouncing from side to side in the Court o' Fear. Costly master's program, bounce, consumed by work, bounce. There are some "popular fiction" programs out there which look promising but I have a great job here in Cleveland that allows me time to finish my bachelor's and write. Bounce, bounce, bounce. Trouble is I don't want to stay in Cleveland whether for writing or education. Bounce. Thank you for your comment, I'm finding this process of thinking and acknowledging my fears very helpful!!

Laurie Erdman's picture

Thank you for sharing your

Thank you for sharing your story. These decisions can seem so hard. I have spent a lot of time with my hard green choices and have come to realize that once i make a choice, others follow.

In my July 3rd Independence post I shared a quote that has helped me make those choices: "Show me what you long for and I will show you who you are." Clearly you are a writer. That comes through loud and clear.

I am a potter. So I had a similar decision to make this last year - get an MFA or not. In making my decision (and the ones that followed from it) I asked myself a few other questions that helped me find my heart's voice. I first asked, "do I need to go back to school to do what I want to do" and "what will that degree/certificate get me?" And to whatever answer I gave to those questions, I would be sure to ask "Is that true?" (thank you Byron Katie). I realized that I didn't need an MFA to make better pots and that having an MFA wouldn't assure that I could make a living from pottery. Decision made.

But I still wanted more time to make pots and to write the book I had growing inside me. That led to another decision point: continue balancing my creative pursuits with my day job, or train for a new career with more flexibility. This was tough. At times it felt like a step backward. But I couldn't shake the vision of my life (thanks to Dana) where I balanced the solitude of pottery and writing with the interaction of coaching clients. So last Friday I signed up for health coaching school. In a year, I can begin to live the life I have been imagining. I only got to this choice with time, asking those questions and letting my heart (not my head) answer.

Wishing you the best in your journey,

Melanie Bates's picture

Laurie

I LOVE that ("show me what you long for...") So, perhaps, like your situation, it's just a matter of time before I'm lead (or I reach) where I'm supposed to be, and maybe it will begin with just one small choice. I just need to sit still long enough to listen. (Your pottery is beautiful, by the way, so it looks like you're definitely on the right path as well.)

Lissa Rankin's picture

My hubby's novel

Melanie,
My hubby still has a novel party written and swirling around in his head. With a four year old running around, he's finding it a little hard to focus, but my agent is chomping at the bit to read his book when the right allows him to finish it!

(By the way, she thanked me for sending her your post :)

n/a
Melanie Bates's picture

Lissa

I always have believed that, in pursuing any passion but especially in regards to my novel, that it has its own time. Perhaps your hubby needs whatever experiences he's gaining at this moment to better complete his work. (Thank you for forwarding my piece :)

Jessica's picture

Beautiful...

Thanks for this gorgeous post! I love the writing - both rich and funny, a hard combo to pull off. :)

At this moment I'm wrestling with one of those green, bitter fruit-choices hanging over the cliff too...do I move to a new town to better pursue my craft and follow my heart, or do I stay in a comfortable town, with a comfortable love...where something feels empty? Am I following my heart and taking risks or am I rationalizing and just transporting all my unanswered questions and unfulfilled hungers down the road?

I, too, believe that the heart knows. I guess I just need to get better at clearing my fears and thoughts and listen closely...

Thanks again for the virtual companionship on the bumpy road...

Melanie Bates's picture

Jessica

We must be on the same psychic wavelength. I am working on a piece (hopefully to be up soon) about this exact same subject. I made the decision to move on to follow my dream but it was tough. That's definitely a decision only you can make but you're so right - it takes "clearing the fears and thoughts" to "listen closely." Love to you, whatever you decide for yourself my companion.

Arizonaheart's picture

The ability to further your

The ability to further your education will always be there. Can you say the same about your desire to write this novel? Will it still be timeley and in demand if you put it off until later? Fold a piece of paper in half, the pros on one half, the cons on the other half. Then count them, that's what I do when I have a 50/50 decision to make.

Melanie Bates's picture

Arizonaheart

You can say that again! I'll be forty this year and have loved being in college as an adult. School will always be there for me, whether I decide to pursue the master's now or later or never. Thank you.

Melanie Bates's picture

Lissa...

Thank you, thank you, and a deep bow. (and me passing out because you'll be sending my words to an agent!) I do indeed need to "be quiet and listen" but all of these exciting signs, and the resulting serendipity, have me higher than my first six cups of coffee in the morning. What did your hubby do instead? Is that novel still roaming around in his head?

Lissa Rankin's picture

Your heart will know

Melanie, what a fabulous post! You'll just have to tweet it to Ellzabeth Law (in fact, it's so great I'm going to send it to my agent, who reps some young adult fantasy!)

When I met my hubby, he was pondering this very quandary- to get an MFA or to finish his novel. Turns out- he did neither. Some seek school as a way to avoid having to face possible failure. If you're in school, you wouldn't be expected to actually finish that novel, send it to agents, deal with the inevitable rejections and see whether it's got the chops to be published, right? If you're in school, you'll be writing every day- but will you be writing what you love?

On the flip side, when you're in school, you might learn some fabulous tools that will grow you as a writer, introduce you to others in your field, glue your arse to the chair, and light a fire under you.

But do you need that? Only your heart knows...
Be quiet. Listen to the still, small voice. You already know the answer....And if you don't, take your time. You will.

Much love
Lissa

n/a

When you comment on an Owning Pink blog post, we invite you to be authentic and loving, to say what you feel, to hold sacred space so others feel heard, and to refrain from using hurtful or offensive language. Differing opinions are welcomed, but if you cannot express yourself in a respectful, caring manner, your comments will be deleted by the Owning Pink staff.