
In response to the Obama Administration’s decision to have insurance companies cover the costs of counseling for battered women, (and other benefits), Fox News contributor Sandy Rios made the following statement:
“Is the White House out of their mind? Does the West Wing not know what the left wing is doing? We’re $14 trillion in debt and now we’re going to cover birth control, breast pumps, counseling for abuse? Are we going to do pedicures and manicures as well?” (Read more here and here.)
This pisses me off! Pedicures and manicures? How can you POSSIBLY compare traumatic healing work to a spa treatment?
As someone who is actively doing healing work of my own, I can't even wrap my head around how anyone could make such a comparison. And to even suggest that a person doesn't deserve to get help, or that it's her fault in the first place.... I don't even know what to say.
I have flames coming out of my ears over this!
These women need love and support and safety to break through the walls that have been put there, not only by themselves in order to survive, but also by the threats and lies of their abusers. And some of these women get into these situations repeatedly because it’s all they’ve ever known. A violent hand is a violent hand whether you’re 5 or 50, and the cycle simply repeats until their survival mechanisms tell them to flee or be killed.
I am fortunate in that I am able to fund my own healing work. But what if I couldn't? What if I made pennies a week and ate SpaghettiO's out of a can every night while sleeping on the floor in some hole-in-the-wall apartment in a neighborhood where I heard gunshots every night, because that was all that I could afford after leaving my sack of crap abusive husband/partner/whoever? Does that mean that I wouldn't deserve to heal? Does my worthiness of a fearless life and a safe awakening depend on how much money I make?
This person obviously doesn't understand what it's like to be afraid, to shake at night because you accidentally burned dinner and he's going to be home in five minutes and you still haven't healed from the other day when you forgot to wash his favorite golf shirt. Or one of the kids accidentally spilled juice on the new carpet and here he comes down the hall and unless you sit on top of that spot forever he’s going to see it and knock you unconscious with whatever is in reach. Or you accidentally spoke out of turn with the guy you've been seeing for a few months and even though you want to leave you can't because you're afraid he's going to kill you if you do.
People who don't know what it's like to be afraid shouldn't make judgments.
I have spent a great deal of time protecting people, these very people, in fact, who don’t know how to protect themselves. I have seen the fear firsthand. I have seen what it does to these women. Until you have sat and held the hand of a woman who is covered in bruises and afraid to go home, who would rather spend the night in a cold and lonely shelter, don’t tell me that she doesn’t deserve whatever help someone is willing to give her, and certainly don’t insult me and these women by comparing trauma healing to manicures.
Most of these women aren’t looking for handouts and don’t want to be perceived as victims.
What they want is to feel safe and to be able to stand tall and proud, knowing that one day they’ll be able to say, “I did this, I overcame this, and now I can help somebody else.” And yes they may humbly take the help that is offered because it’s the only way, but I guarantee you these women will find a way to pay it forward somewhere down the line.
You know her, the one who got married straight out of high school and who showed up on a friend’s doorstep with nowhere to go and no work experience and no life experience because she's been a prisoner in her own house for 15 years and has three little mouths to feed and priorities piling up that don't include how she's going to pay for the therapy she desperately needs to undo all the horror she's seen so she can sleep through the night without waking up screaming or crying or both? Tell me she doesn't deserve a little help.
These women have somehow managed to come out of horrible situations where they’re beaten and left empty shells of who they once were and now someone wants to complain that if we’re going to give out counseling to these women we may as well give out manicures as well? Like they haven’t been insulted enough?
If I had my way I’d drag this Fox News contributor straight down to a battered women’s shelter and have her listen to these women’s stories. I’d make her look in their fear-filled eyes that are searching intently to determine if you’re safe. I’d make her watch every time one of these women jumps at an unexpected noise and then apologizes and starts to cry because she feels shame for what somewhat else did to her.
Don’t tell me these women don’t deserve to heal. They are survivors, every one of them, and they deserve our respect. There is a strength that comes from being a survivor. These women aren’t weak like some may think, they are strong beyond measure.
Sometimes a person just needs a hand reaching through the darkness to hold onto until they can stand on their own. And there is NOTHING wrong with that.
If you are one of those women who needs to heal, you can do this, I believe in you. And if you are one of the women who has healed and come through the other side, help somebody else, today.
With love and compassion for all these strong women,
April
April Sweazy is a kick-ass writer from Rochester, NY and is currently working on her first novel.
April Sweazy
www.april-sweazy.com
When you comment on an Owning Pink blog post, we invite you to be authentic and loving, to say what you feel, to hold sacred space so others feel heard, and to refrain from using hurtful or offensive language. Differing opinions are welcomed, but if you cannot express yourself in a respectful, caring manner, your comments will be deleted by the Owning Pink staff.
Comments
very deeply touched...
By Anonymous (not verified) on Friday, 09/02/2011 at 3:35 AMApril, you are a kick-ass writer! Thank you for speaking out for all of us who can't muster up a voice against our perpetrators. Your heartfelt words and genuine compassion are very touching and deeply appreciated. Namaste.
battered women
By Paula Zijlstra (not verified) on Saturday, 08/13/2011 at 10:03 AMthe world is mad only thinking of money not about aid. so called bathered women are in the eyes of soo many losers, that's what i think. lots of people were broad up with the idea that our world is about winners (the strong) and losers (the weak). It's jungle language. but we are not living in the jungle we are humans and have to learn to differentiate ourselves from animals by using the empathy i.s.o. the jungle rules.
i think the strong are here to help the weak in stead of bully them.
To Battered Women Everywhere
By Melissa (not verified) on Saturday, 08/13/2011 at 8:41 AMPhysical and emotional abuse is a disease that is passed down from generation to generation in many families. How many generations of women in your family have been living in fear?
The notion of a strong woman with healthy self esteem was virtually unknown in my family. I was raised to believe that women are not as intelligent or capable as men. I was 40 years old before I realized that I could achieve anything I really wanted in life. Now, after years of struggle, I know that I am a survivor. I don't need the approval of a man, or anyone else to know that what I have to offer the world matters!
Melissa you are so right
By April Sweazy (not verified) on Saturday, 08/13/2011 at 8:34 PMYes, what you have to offer the world does matter! I am 32 and just discovering that I control my life and that the negativity that has been passed down through the generations of my family does not have to be a continuing part of me and my story. I have everything in me to create the life that I want and deserve. And so do you!
Much Love,
April
Props.
By notsofast (not verified) on Thursday, 08/11/2011 at 5:21 AMThank you. That's it. Just thanks. From a DV survivor.
Thank you!
By April Sweazy (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/09/2011 at 1:07 PMLissa, I so appreciate the opportunity to speak and be heard and rant about this subject that deserves more attention.
Pearl - Thank you for sharing your story! you are an inspiration to others who wonder if they have the strength to make that scary step of leaving, not knowing what lies ahead for them.
Yes I agree that this attitude is inexcusable, especially from the media. We can make a difference one blog, one voice, and one comment at a time.
Amen, April
By Lissa Rankin on Tuesday, 08/09/2011 at 8:19 AMWhere does she get off? I mean SERIOUSLY? Mani/pedis and restraining orders? WTF?
I love what you wrote and totally 1000% agree with you. Thank you for ranting so beautifully. I couldn't have said it this well myself.
With wild applause and lots of love for battered women everywhere
Lissa
As someone who took my kids
By Pearl (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/09/2011 at 8:09 AMAs someone who took my kids and ran out of a relationship with restraining order and divorce papers in hand, I can honestly say that I feel sorry for people like her who can't look past people like me for the situation I was in instead of the person I am.
Not all survivors live off the system or accept government handouts. I survived 100% on my own without aide and I'm proud of the home I've created for myself and my kids. We, survivors, don't expect to have our hands held and don't want sympathy or pitty. But a little RESPECT would go a long way. I've worked hard these past 5 years to better myself and be a provider. To get an education and a job I can be proud of. And to be the parent my kids deserve.
Sandy Rios makes it seem like all victims are social misfits that don't deserve the same rights she does. If all she's worried about is the $14 trillion debt our country has, maybe she should be seeking to overall the entire system instead of trying to beat down people that have already been beaten down and have no where to go but up.
Pearl
One last thing...
By Michelle Wallace (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/09/2011 at 7:16 AMThe following ending quote illustrates just how uneducated and willfully ignorant her viewpoints actually are..
“You all make science a laughing stock. You present science and facts just to present your viewpoint.”
- Sandy Rios
wow
By Michelle Wallace (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/09/2011 at 6:59 AMApril, your words are beautiful. This person's attitude is definitely inexcusable. And it saddens me that there are still people out there who are only interested in themselves and can't see past their own experiences. Self-centredness is appalling.
Thank you, April. Attitudes
By Lindley @ Amethyst and Amber (not verified) on Tuesday, 08/09/2011 at 6:15 AMThank you, April. Attitudes like that are simply inexcusable. It seems to be an offshoot of the right-wing belief that poor people are poor because they're lazy: that bad things only happen to people who deserve it. I wonder if that sort of belief is really based in fear. "I'm a good person, so this sort of thing couldn't possibly happen to me. If it happened to them, they must have done something to deserve it."
Either way, not acceptable, particularly from the media, who have so much power.