Owning Pink Bloggers

You'll never face something in life that you can't handle.

Why I’m Pissed At Doctors

Lissa Rankin's picture

doctor heart medicine

Over the summer, I wrote a love letter to doctors intended to help me release some of the charge I still feel regarding the way doctors have treated me throughout my medical training and in my old practice. I wrote the letter as a letter of forgiveness, but I recently did a session with an energy healer and realized that I still carry some old baggage around this issue.

I was already feeling a little wounded regarding my relationship with doctors as a whole. Just to clarify, I have many personal friendships with doctors whom I love very much. My father was a doctor. And I am a doctor. So I’m not some doctor-basher standing in the wings. When I say I’m pissed at doctors, I include the doctor I was (until four years ago) on the list of docs I want to give a piece of my mind.

What I’m referring to is not any individual doctor. I’m talking about doctors with a capital “D.” I’m referring to the institution. The American Medical Association. The colleges and medical schools that train doctors. The collective body of doctorhood. You get the picture. This is what I mean when I say I’m pissed at doctors. I’m embarrassed, ashamed, and horrified at what is happening to my profession, and as someone from within it, I think it’s high time to speak up.

Yesterday, I got an email from a friend of mine who just came back from seeing a doctor.

Here’s what she said.

Lissa, if this doctor robs me as I leave the building, I wouldn't be able to confirm it was him, as I don’t think he looked at me once. From the nurse intake to the actual exam room, both practitioners faced AWAY from me, towards their computer terminals, while they asked me questions and clicked away at the keyboard. The computer fed him my new prescription, and he never even discussed it with me. I am as disgusted as I am bewildered. If a computer program is all I need to monitor and refill prescriptions on my current or chronic conditions, then what the flying furry F-CK am I doing spending an hour in a waiting room, waiting to look at some guy's back?!? Oh, and don't forget -- the nurse clearly put a wrong code into the computer, because he came in prepared to give me a BREAST exam, rather than listening to my asthmatic CHEST. I was like,"What are you talking about, sir? You have the wrong information or else the wrong room." Sigh. I’m so so so so mad right now. I’m never coming here ever again. You keep to doing it the right way, sister. I appreciate you so much.

This email prompted me to take a long hike on a remote ocean view trail far from civilization. The more I thought about it, the more angry I became, until I finally stopped, planted my feet on the earth, raised my arms, and screamed. Literally, I stood there like a crazy person and shrieked until my throat hurt. And then my screaming turned to tears, until I was sobbing uncontrollably, blubbering, hot, fierce tears of anger, sadness, and hurt that lasted almost two hours.

Why was I crying?

Because they hurt me, those doctors. I led a sheltered life as a child. With loving parents and a nurturing home life, I wasn’t prepared for the abuse that started in medical school. The innocent, naïve 22 year-old I was didn’t know how to cope with surgeons throwing scalpels at me, doctors sexually harassing me, or teachers forcing me to take anti-nausea medication and wear Depends so I could scrub into surgery when I had the flu. I didn’t know how to handle the professor who said, “I didn’t even go to my own father’s funeral” when I begged for two days off so I could attend my grandmother’s wake. I wasn’t prepared to cope with sleep deprivation and meal-skipping that left me weighing 100 pounds at 5’5” tall, and vicious, threatening verbal attacks from narcissistic doctors hell bent on knocking me down.

But it’s more than that, really. I was also crying for the doctors with their backs to patients and their hands on doorknobs, ready to bolt. I cried for my boss who forced me to see 40 patients a day until I quit practicing medicine for two years because I knew it wasn’t supposed to be this way. I cried over managed care and malpractice attorneys and technological “advances” that have turned many doctors into highly skilled mechanics who don’t have a clue how to be with a human. I cried because nobody ever taught me in medical school that there’s a difference between healing and curing, and that you can cure without healing or heal without curing.

Something has happened, at least in the United States, that has made doctors lose the heart of medicine. Too many docs have gone from being healers to being doctorbots who churn through patients in 7½ minutes. Even mechanics spend more time with their “patients” than they do these days.

And where is the love? 

Before antibiotics, chemotherapy, safe surgery, and other modern inventions, all doctors could really do was sit at the bedside and attend to the family when someone was ill. Now we have vaccinations and ventilators and virus-fighting medications, but look what we’ve lost. We’ve lost bedside manner, hand-holding, and hugs.

I don’t claim to have all the answers, but I know that I’m doing what’s right for me. And I’m not alone in the desire for this kind of medicine. People want to reclaim the heart of medicine. Most of us just don’t know where to start.

I know things can change. But it takes awareness.

What do you think? Have you had tough doctor experiences? Is your doctor there for you? Do you feel heard and understood? Do you steer clear of doctors? Tell us what you think.

Holding out for the heart of medicine,

Lissa Rankin, MD



Lissa Rankin's picture

gentle phoenix wings

Oh littlephoenix, thank you! (*wipes tears*) I so appreciate your compassion. Thank you. Bless you.

littlephoenix's picture

Compassion is essential

Your post and the discussion of what you went through as a 22 year old really struck a chord in me. I've recently been doing a lot of thinking/processing around things my age 12 self went through, and how much it still hurts at times. I'm realizing that what my younger self didn't have was someone to listen to her and be compassionate, and it seems like the way to heal from the past stuff is to have compassion for our younger selves and validate their pain and their bravery. It can be so hard to have compassion for ourselves at times. One thing I am beginning (very slowly!) to learn to do is to say something like "If my younger self were a separate person that I wanted to comfort, what would I say?" and then to try to reflect that caring back on myself. I know that when I read your post, I just wanted to hug that 22 year old and reassure her. So I guess what I'm saying is that by sharing what you did, I'm finding compassion for my younger self via thinking about ways I would have acted to comfort your younger self... I think I'm starting to go in circles and ramble here, though. :)

littlephoenix's picture

I am so sorry

Dear Lissa,

I am so sorry about what you experienced in medical school. When I first read this post, tears came to my eyes at all you had been put through. My heart was breaking for you and your younger self. To go through all that and still have such a dedication to caring for people... well, to me that shows real courage.

I hope the crying helped, at least somewhat. Sometimes I find that's all you can do. Sometimes it's what we *need* to do.

Please be kind to yourself (including your younger self)--these kinds of experiences can be so draining. (Sometimes what I do is to make hot chocolate and wrap up in a blanket.)

Wrapping gentle phoenix wings around you,

When you comment on an Owning Pink blog post, we invite you to be authentic and loving, to say what you feel, to hold sacred space so others feel heard, and to refrain from using hurtful or offensive language. Differing opinions are welcomed, but if you cannot express yourself in a respectful, caring manner, your comments will be deleted by the Owning Pink staff.